PHOENIX (AZFamily) — Progress Residential, the country’s biggest property manager of single-family homes, is paying $49.75 million to settle claims brought by the Federal Trade Commission and four states, including Arizona.
The FTC says the company misled consumers for years and cost renters tens of millions of dollars.
Samantha Fequiere, a Progress Residential tenant, said she is getting ready to move out of her rental after less than a year.
“I kind of feel like I’m in a bad relationship. I’ve got to just get out,” she said.
Fequiere said she has had problems with the property manager, including a dispute about payments and repair requests that went unanswered.
“A ticket was open. Somebody would come in and say, ‘Oh, I can’t fix that screen on the window. I can’t fix this. I can’t fix that,’ and then after they’ve kind of shined you on they close the ticket,” Fequiere said.
Claims in the complaint
In a complaint, the FTC and four states, including Arizona, said Progress Residential:
Advertised false rental prices
Failed to inspect homes before people moved in
Improperly deducted money from security deposits
Restricted negative reviews
Failed to provide adequate customer service
Charged hidden fees, including a smart home fee and a renter’s insurance exemption fee
Fequiere said the company told her she needed $100,000 of insurance for the property.
“If you went without the insurance, you were charged $15,” she said.
Fequiere said she paid the $15 every month because she couldn’t get the required coverage.
“I would call insurance companies, and they said, ‘Well, what do you have that’s worth $100,000?’ And I was like, ‘I’m not that wealthy. I don’t think I have anything.’”
Changes to the business
As part of the settlement, Progress Residential will make changes to its business. The company will advertise a true total monthly rental price and establish a security deposit refund process. It will also not deduct money from security deposits for normal wear and tear.
“I am extremely relieved,” Fequiere said.
In a statement, Progress Residential said: “Although we disagree with the FTC’s claims, this resolution allows us to move forward with our mission of expanding access to quality, affordable rental housing in neighborhoods of opportunity.”
The FTC does not yet have information about how and when consumers will be paid.
See a spelling or grammatical error in our story? Please click here to report it.
Do you have a photo or video of a breaking news story? Send it to us here with a brief description.
Copyright 2026 KTVK/KPHO. All rights reserved.